Homes & Cottages

ALL-STAR OHIO HOUSEbuckeye_house
394 Loraine Avenue
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
Downtown Map 56

The All-Star Ohio House is an historical and entertaining family and group friendly rental home located 200 feet from downtown Put-in-Bay, Ohio. Five bedrooms and three bathrooms accommodate up to 22 guests. A/C, Cable TV, Gas BBQ, corn hole, private backyard. Sheets, towels and linens are provided. Guests also enjoy use of Put-in-Bay Resort’s pool, just 500 feet away.



Chapman Road
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
Island Map 57

If you want to experience island life in the summer, this classic island cottage is a 10 minute walk from downtown and has a spectacular view of Perry’s Victory and International Peace Memorial and Lake Erie. Ray’s has two bedrooms, a bath with shower, AC, full kitchen, sun deck in back, and a screened front porch. There is also a gas grill and picnic table to enjoy. There is lake access, but overnight docking is not allowed. There is an adjacent play area for the kids. Bring along your own linens and towels. No laundry.



410 Loraine Avenue
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
Downtown Map 58

Amorris Guest House is located 1/2 block from downtown Put-in-Bay. Enjoy the convenience of being within walking distance of the shops, restaurants, bars and attractions. Sleeps up to 8 guests. Three bedrooms, two full baths, AC, microwave and coffee maker. Fresh linens and towels provided. Screened in porch


A PLACE AT THE BAYaplaceatthebay
1559 Jeris Lane
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
Island Map 60

A Place at the Bay has four bedrooms, two full baths and a Jacuzzi master suite that accommodates up to 12 people. Located on 1.5 acres on Put-in-Bay Road, across from the entrance to the Island Club. Fully equipped kitchen, wooded lot, near the South Bass Island State Park and boat access to Lake Erie. Pool privleges for all guests nearby.




402 Loraine Avenue
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
Downtown Map 61

Victorian Home located in the center of town. One block from downtown shops, restaurants & bars, with downtown pool access. All three floors have 3 bedrooms, 1 full bath, and a complete kitchen. Each floor sleeps up to 8 people & can be rented separately or together. Weekly, weekend & midweek rentals available.



426 Loraine Avenue
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
Downtown Map 62

Older Victorian home located in the heart of downtown Put-in-Bay. Walking distance to all the shops, restaurants, bars, attractions and the Jet Express. Home features five bedrooms, two full baths and a complete kitchen. Sleeps up to 16 comfortably. Downtown pool privileges. Weekly, weekend and midweek rentals available.


Formerly QE Bay Properties

206 Toledo Avenue
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
Downtown Map 74

This landmark island home was once owned by island photographer Otto Herbster. The house has a beautifully decorated living room, and large kitchen with an open floor plan. There are three bedrooms, a full bath, and half bath. Located just across the street from the Depot, downtown shops, the Perry Memorial, restaurants, entertainment, and taverns, and attractions. Just a block away from the Jet Express dock, and right across the street from the Depot where the downtown bus operates between Put-in-Bay and the Miller Ferry dock.


500 Catawba Avenue
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
Downtown Map 42

Classic lake-style cottage.  A/C, large living room, 2 bedrooms, 1 bath, fully equipped galley kitchen, microwave, TV, DVD, satellite, wireless internet, propane grill, fire pit, close to pools, hairdryers, robes, linens/towels.  Sleeps up to 6, steps to downtown, small dogs allowed, centrally located, friendly staff, great amenities. Walk to Jet Express.  NON-SMOKING.  Perfect for families or groups.  Weekly, weekend and mid-week rates.  Internet specials.   VISA/MC/AMEX



Bath Street
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
Downtown Map 63

Quaint island cottages on Bath Street just a half a block from Put-in-Bay’s downtown on the lake with a picturesque view of the lake and Kelleys Island. Weekend, weekday or weekly rental. Great for families, friends and fishermen. Linens are not provided.




Langram Road
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
419-285-6119 summer
Island Map

The Bird’s Nest Resort offers two and three bedroom cottages. Fully equipped kitchens, living room has color TV, screened porches with tables and chairs, swimming pool, fish cleaning facilities, grills, play area, pets welcome. Rent by week or weekend. Cottages have plenty of room to enjoy outdoors as well.




West Shore
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
Island Map 64

Blue Sky Rentals has two houses for rent on Put-in-Bay.  The Westwind is Put-in-Bay’s premier lakefront rental property. Located on West Shore Blvd, the Westwind is 1500 sq ft of fabulous living space. With a large front porch and a 30′ by 20′ deck on the lakefront with spectacular views of Lake Erie and sensational sunsets.  The Lighthouse is a beautiful 3 bedroom, 2 full bath, fully furnished home, nicely appointed with an excellent interior layout. Features include a patio with a grill, picnic tables and patio chairs for outdoor grilling/lounging and pool access which is across the street from the Lighthouse.



Mike’s Drive
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
Island Map 66

Poor Man’s Nantucket is located on a quiet lane on South Bass Island’s East Point. The Salt Box home sits on one acre of landscaped yard and has two bedrooms, 2 1/2 baths, central A/C, finished basement living area, loft, w/b fireplace, Jacuzzi, two decks, screened porch. Sleeps 6. Rented weekly.


1961 Langram Rd 
Captains Quarters
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456

Island Map

Luxury accommodations for up to 6 people.  House includes two bedrooms, one bath, all wood interior with lofted ceilings, full kitchen, living room and spacious outdoor area with grill, corn hole game and picnic area.  Great place to relax and unwind and leave your worries behind!   One block from the Miller Ferry dock and 2 miles from downtown.  Public transportation at the street or discounted golf cart rentals available.  Two night minimum stay and great weekly rates!

Mike’s Drive
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
Island Map 67

This charming Cape Cod cottage was once the original Poor Man’s Nantucket. Main house has four bedrooms, three full baths and sleeps up to 12 people. The guest house sleeps up to six. Lots of room, large landscaped lot. Great for family vacations. TV with cable, VCR, fully equipped kitchens, grills, outdoor eating and entertaining area, and more.



CHALET AT THE BAYchalet_atthebay
Put-in-Bay Road
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
Island Map 68

Chalet at the Bay has four bedrooms and two baths and a fully equipped kitchen. A TV & VCR and lots of seating for a large family. This home sits on an acre of wooded land in the center of the island. There also are two charcoal grills & a fire pit. Nice family vacation home.



Bay View Avenue
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
Downtown Map 69

Waterfront lodging overlooking the island’s Bay, one block from downtown. Between the Yacht Club & Crew’s Nest. Sleeps up to 20. Great for a special family reunion and groups. Whole house or subdivide. Two fully equipped kitchens, outdoor gas grill, picnic tables, bed linens, towels & wash cloths. Directv satellite service. Midweek membership at Crew’s Nest (located next door) available with pool, restaurant and club amenities.



631 Trenton Avenue and 811 Maple
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
Island Map 70

D Cottage Rentals offer two, three and four bedroom cottages, for up to six, eight or ten persons, depending on cottage. Cottages have 1 1/2 or 2 full baths. Fully equipped kitchens, color TV, VCR, stereo, private deck and grill. Linens provided. Wooded settings.



247 Erie Street
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
Downtown Map 71

Hotel, town houses, and suites clean, modern, one block from down town, reasonably priced with accommodations for two to ten guests. All facilities have private baths, AC, refrigerators, cable, WIFI, pool privileges, and many more special features.



Langram Road
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
Island Map

Three fully furnished lake cottages, two located on the South Shore on the lakefront, and the third located near the West Shore in the woods. Linens and towels are provided at all three, and each cabin sleeps up to six people. Kitchens have the basic utensils needed for cooking, and each cabin has a grill, but you need to bring your own charcoal. The cottages are air-conditioned, have TVs with basic channels, and DVD players, so bring some movies along.




141 Massie Drive
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456

Island Map 73

Put-in-Bay Cabins offer a 2 or 3 bedroom cabin, or both , fully furnished with fully equipped kitchens.  Put-in-Bay Cabins are located on a quiet lane on East Point. Trees surround each cabin which adds to the relaxing atmosphere. Both cabins have decks, gas grills, and picnic tables. There are private campfire rings provided for each cabin for sitting around a campfire in the evenings,and there are horseshoe pits, and a volleyball net for those wanting a little activity. Perry’s Monument is with in walking distance. The shops, and Put-in-Bay’s other attractions are just a short ride away.




770 Evelyn Road
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
Island Map 60

Two eight-person suites in a duplex with an adjoining locking door that can accommodate your entire family. Each unit has a full kitchen and two full baths, private porch. Great for family reunions and “bachelorette” parties. Private one acre setting. Located near the Island Club.



99 Regatta Drive
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
Island Map 64

Fully furnished three-bedroom, two-bath home for up to 8 people in the Island Club. A fully equipped kitchen with microwave, coffee maker and toaster. Patio with grill and picnic table. 40″ flat screen TV with DVD and satellite, Air Conditioning. Blankets and pillows are provided. Bring your sheets and towels. Nice wooded lot. A home away from home feel!


1233 Fox Road
Middle Bass, OH 43446
Island Map 72

St. Hazard’s on Middle Bass has small cabins for rent for four & villas for up to six people that have a tropical theme. Located at St. Hazard’s Village, just a 5-minute ferry ride from downtown Put-in-Bay. Microbrewery, restaurant and swimming pool on premises.


Catawba Ave. Victory Place_1
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456

Property Rental Link:

Located near the South Bass Island State Park, this 5-7 bedroom Historic Home features a large living room, dining room, kitchen, and laundry facility. Outside amenities include fire pit, volley ball or bring the corn hole! Plenty of space for outside fun! The entire home can be rented or as two separate units.

Unit 1- is the Victory Place main home space as described above and can be 4-5 bedrooms, with two bathrooms.
Unit 2: East-West Shore-6 people/couples with living room space and kitchenette, one bathroom and an outside deck for grilling and enjoying the islands fresh air!